City on a Hill

The idea of America as a "city on a hill" is a powerful, enduring metaphor, and in this episode, we explore the concept through an urban planning lens. With talk with Alex Krieger on his book, City on a Hill: A History of American Urban Planning, which argues that America's built environment is a direct reflection of its utopian ideals—for better or for worse.

Listen Now

Krieger’s work posits that from the Pilgrims' vision of a "New Jerusalem" to Thomas Jefferson's dream of a nation of citizen farmers, America has consistently tried to shape its physical landscape to match its philosophical aspirations. The book, and by extension the podcast, explores how these ideals have manifested in city design throughout history:

• The Puritan Village: The structured, communal villages of New England are early examples of a planned society based on shared values.

• The Grid: The rational, gridded layout of cities, famously championed by Jefferson, represents an attempt to impose order and equality on the vast American wilderness.

• The City Beautiful Movement: As industrialization led to urban decay, reformers responded with a zealous crusade for grand civic architecture and sweeping public parks, like New York's Central Park, to create beautiful, moralizing spaces.

• Suburban Sprawl: In the 20th century, the utopian ideal shifted to the suburbs, promising a perfect, single-family home life that, in turn, created car-dependent and often socially isolating communities.

The conversation reveals that these cycles of utopian dreaming have left a lasting legacy. For every successful park or vibrant downtown, there is a failed urban renewal project or a sprawling, unsustainable suburb.

Understanding this history is critical for modern-day planners. It shows that current urban challenges—from inequality to climate change—are not new but rather the result of a long, often contradictory, history of idealism. By examining the successes and failures of past visions, planners can avoid repeating mistakes and learn to create new, more inclusive, and sustainable utopias. The ultimate goal, as the podcast and book suggest, is to build cities that don't just aspire to be a "city on a hill," but that truly live up to the promise of serving all their citizens.